At the business end of the review, we have to say that CyberLink has got its strategy right. At present, they seem to be the only vendor in the HTPC Blu-ray / DVD software space with a strategy for the next generation of media playback devices. In fact, CyberLink also showed their softwares in action in the Windows 8 Metro UI during CES. CyberLink deserves a lot of credit for moving ahead quickly in this area. However, all the components have scope for improvement, and we also have some suggestions on possible features to integrate in the future:

PowerDVD:

  1. The software needs an option to turn off Internet access unless explicitly requested by the user (as in the case of BD-Live). Whenever one tries to resume a movie, PowerDVD fetches information about the latest Blu-rays and displays it in a pane on the right side while presenting the Resume / Restart screen. Frankly, I don’t see too many consumers actually being interested in looking at the new offerings when trying to restart their movies.
  2. The software could implement native support for Blu-ray / DVD ISOs, thereby making it unnecessary for users to mount them in a virtual drive. Compatibility with folder rips could be improved.
  3. It would be nice to have the audio playback method (bitstream / decode / downmix) selectable from the context menu during playback. By default, most users with A/V receivers would be setting the audio method to bitstream. When watching PiP video, it is necessary to decode the primary audio and mix it with the decoded secondary audio. Unfortunately, PowerDVD keeps bitstreaming the primary audio and there is no way out other than to go a couple of levels down into Settings and Audio to fix the issue. In my opinion, the drop-down approach from the AV Center used by Total Media Theater is much better.
  4. It would be good to have PowerDVD bypass the sound processing by Windows (particularly when decoding, say, a 5.1 channel FLAC to LPCM, Windows expands the 6 channel LPCM from PowerDVD to a 8 channel LPCM stream to the AV receiver, rendering the AVR incapable of doing its own channel expansion)
  5. Auto change to 3D mode is a bit dicey, particularly for 3D photo files, but one can’t find too much fault with PowerDVD for that.
  6. It is interesting to see premium media outlets like 7Digital adopting PowerDVD as a distribution medium. Having used PCs as their stepping stone, premium OTT services such as Netflix now treat them as poor second cousins. 1080p HD quality and multi-channel DD+ audio are reserved for streaming STBs. Some of the reasons cited for this are lack of playback apps on the PC with the required codec licenses and security of the data stream. Given that PowerDVD is secure enough for Blu-ray and also has the required codec licenses, it would be nice to have the highest quality streams from Netflix, Vudu and other similar services made available to consumers

PowerDVD Mobile:

  1. Despite CyberLink’s claims of real-time transcoding to enable DLNA playback, we could get transcoding to work only when saving the media stream to the mobile device. Also, this transcoding doesn’t seem to be taking advantage of QuickSync.
  2. Multiple player engine support is crucial. Currently, the app relies only on hardware decode (using the default playback settings of the local device as defined in the OS/image of the tablet/smartphone). I found a number of dedicated uPnP playback apps which played more media formats in a reliable manner compared to PowerDVD Mobile.
  3. Media can only be arranged by folders or in an all-inclusive view. Support for arrangement based on other factors (like date, size etc.) would be a nice feature to have.
  4. The app already supports local media. It would be nice to extend this support to media files residing on SMB and NFS network shares also.
  5. The app could be made more responsive. Currently, it feels very beta in nature. Performance was acceptable, but not great. It is not clear whether the issues were with the platforms or the app itself, but I did find other dedicated uPnP playback apps a pleasure to use.

PowerDVD Remote:

  1. The app could have a landscape mode option along with orientation auto-detection.

Wrapping things up, PowerDVD 12 is a laudable attempt by CyberLink to adapt to the evolving lifestyle of the consumers. As the tablet and smartphone platforms become more pervasive, CyberLink seems to be best poised to provide users with compelling offerings. Given that almost all Blu-ray / DVD software players come in at approximately the same price ($100), it looks like a no-brainer to go in with PowerDVD 12 because of the various mobile apps (unless you can purchase the competition's offerings at a much lower price).





 

PowerDVD Mobile v4
Comments Locked

41 Comments

View All Comments

  • sholling - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    It seems like the only real change from 11 to 12 is the ability to get rid of the giant advertizement screen. The settings screen still doesn't let you change audio defaults or at least make them stay changed, and it still doesn't support ISOs despite the feature chart. I wish the reviewer had actually tested that feature because it would have saved me $50. Net time I'll be a lot less trusting when a reviewer here makes a claim.
  • ganeshts - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    Whoa! Of course it plays ISOs when it is mounted with Virtual Clone Drive. Definitely tested and it works.
  • ganeshts - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    And of course, I have mentioned that in the concluding section too:


    The software could implement native support for Blu-ray / DVD ISOs, thereby making it unnecessary for users to mount them in a virtual drive.


    Next time around, it would be really nice to not blame the reviewer when the necessary information is actually available in the review and is clearly explained.
  • sholling - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    If BD ISO is going to be claimed in the table then it needs to be in reference to direct support not through a some 3rd party tool that's doing the heavy lifting. Any program can access an ISO if a 3rd party program is doing the work for it. The author needs to go back and correct the table to read "ISOs supported through 3rd party tools only". Many readers are going to be coming from appliances alike the WDTV Live and NeoTV550 where BD ISO support actually means BD ISO support.
  • sholling - Wednesday, February 1, 2012 - link

    BTW Other than the ISO thing it was a nice review.
  • cjs150 - Thursday, February 2, 2012 - link

    I have had bad experiences - never again.

    If I like a Blu ray I will rip it off the disc down to my NAS (any number of programs can do this) and then replay using a low power HTPC (still looking for the perfect one).

    Yes it may be a grey area but my standalone Blu-ray player does a brilliant job - until you get to a quiet bit in the movie. I want to hear the movie not the Blu-ray player (to be fair it is probably just sound of disc going round at high revs).

    I particularly enjoyed the lack of support for forced sub-titles - so when I watch Battle of Britain and Germans are speaking German I will not get the sub-title translations?
  • ganeshts - Thursday, February 2, 2012 - link

    Forced subtitles work off Blu-rays, just not off standalone files.

    The advantages of ripping a Blu-ray to disk are many, but not everyone wants to do that (and it is definitely a legally gray area at least in the US)
  • Golgatha - Thursday, February 2, 2012 - link

    There is nothing grey about it. The DMCA makes it completely illegal to do a legally grey thing. Namely the exercise of your fair use rights. Sorry to derail the thread. Nice review of apparently improved software (since I last used it anyway). Customer service, cost of upkeep, and support of the product should be in the review too. Those are the main reasons I chose ArcSoft's TMT5.
  • maglito - Thursday, February 2, 2012 - link

    It seems no software player supports this niche. It makes plenty of sense for current HTPC projector owners to get a 2nd projector identical to their current one(cheaply on the used market), some passive filters, cheap $1/pair glasses and possibly go to a silver screen depending on what they use(if their current screen won't maintain polarization of the reflected light). In fact JVC projectors are ideal for this as all colors are already polarized at 0 degrees (I have a JVC RS-1 from back in 2006 and I know Anand got a RS-2 shortly after).

    If any video card manufacturer or media player software supported this output type from 3d Blu Ray or 3D MKV files that would help many people investigating this solution out tremendously. The current work arounds to make this work are a bit of a joke.

    As usual, nice write up Ganesh.
  • justniz - Thursday, February 2, 2012 - link

    I never liked the way PowerDVD apparently has to take over your whole system just to play a DVD.

    Does PowerDVD 12 still need to switch your whole GUI from glass mode to basic mode when it runs? That was always retarded, especially on PCs with high end video cards.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now